Table of Contents
Get this article emailed to you .
Are you curious about how Svelte's compiler-based approach differs from React's runtime?
Do you wonder how reactivity works in each framework and how they handle state management?
Are you interested in learning how the simplicity of Svelte's code compares to React's JSX syntax?
In this article, we will dive into the key differences between Svelte and React, comparing their approaches to compilation, reactivity, simplicity, and overall developer experience . By the end, you'll have a better understanding of what sets these frameworks apart and be equipped to choose the right one for your next project.
Architectural Differences: Svelte as a compiler vs. React's runtime
Svelte's compiler-based approach
It's important to note that Svelte offers other interesting features, which you can learn more about in this post: Svelte vs. SvelteKit: The Difference.
Here is the code generated by the Svelte compiler for the reactivity example we will see below:
React's Virtual DOM and runtime
React, on the other hand, uses a Virtual DOM to manage changes to the application's state. The Virtual DOM is an in-memory representation of the actual DOM, and React updates this virtual representation whenever a change occurs. Once the Virtual DOM has been updated, React compares it to the actual DOM and applies the minimal set of changes required, a process known as "reconciliation ."
The Virtual DOM approach allows React to batch updates and optimize rendering performance. However, this also means that React applications need to ship with a runtime framework, which can lead to larger bundle sizes compared to Svelte.
Reactivity in Svelte and React
Reactivity is a fundamental aspect of modern web development, allowing for efficient updates to the UI as the application state changes. Both Svelte and React offer unique approaches to handling reactivity, which we will explore below.
How does reactivity work in Svelte?
In Svelte, reactivity is built into the language itself. To create a reactive variable, you simply use the
keyword. Whenever the value of the reactive variable changes, Svelte automatically updates the DOM to reflect the change.
Check out this blog post by Rich Harris, the creator of Svelte, to understand the language's approach to reactivity: Svelte 3: Rethinking reactivity
Here's an example of a simple counter component in Svelte:
Svelte also provides built-in stores, which can be used for more advanced state management. Stores are essentially containers for reactive values that can be shared across multiple components
. To create a store, you can use the
function from the
Here's an example of using a store in Svelte:
In the above example, the
symbol is used by Svelte to mark a statement as reactive.
How does reactivity work in React?
React handles reactivity through its state management system. In class components, you would use the
method to update the state and trigger a re-render. In more recent versions of React, the introduction of hooks allows for a more functional approach to state management. The
hook is used to declare a state variable and provides a function to update its value.
Here's an example of a simple counter component in React using hooks:
For more advanced state management in React, developers often use external libraries like Redux, Jotai, or Recoil.
Comparing the Reactivity Approaches
Svelte's reactivity model is built into the language, making it straightforward to create reactive variables and update the DOM automatically. React, on the other hand, relies on its state management system, which has evolved from class components to hooks for functional components. Both frameworks provide ways to handle complex state management, with Svelte offering built-in stores and React relying on external libraries .
The choice between Svelte and React's reactivity models depends on your project's needs and your personal preference as a developer.
When comparing Svelte and React, one of the most noticeable differences is in their syntax and the way they structure components . This section will showcase the syntax differences between the two frameworks and how it affects code simplicity.
, making them easily understandable for developers who are familiar with these languages. Each Svelte component consists of a single
file, which can include a
tag for CSS, and an HTML markup for the component's structure.
Here's an example of a simple Svelte component:
This syntax is intuitive and easy to read, as it closely resembles the structure of a typical HTML file.
React's Use of JSX
Here's an example of a simple React component using JSX:
In this example, the component's styles are imported from a separate CSS file, and the
attribute is used instead of the standard
attribute to apply styles.
A comparison of the syntax and code complexity
When choosing between Svelte and React, consider how the syntax and simplicity of each framework align with your personal preferences and the needs of your project. Both frameworks have their strengths, and the choice ultimately depends on what you find most comfortable and efficient to work with.
Developer Experience: Svelte vs. React
Developer experience is an important aspect to consider when choosing a framework, as it can directly affect productivity, code maintainability, and overall enjoyment of the development process.
Svelte's Developer Experience
Svelte has garnered praise for its simplicity and ease of use, which contributes to a positive developer experience. Some aspects that developers appreciate include:
Minimal boilerplate : Svelte components require little boilerplate code, resulting in cleaner and more readable files.
Reactivity : Svelte's built-in reactivity makes it easy to manage the state and update the UI automatically when the state changes.
Built-in features : Svelte includes features like built-in stores and transitions, which can simplify state management and animations without the need for external libraries.
React's Developer Experience
React has been a popular choice among developers for years and offers a mature and well-documented ecosystem. Some aspects of React's developer experience include:
Component-based architecture : React's component-based architecture promotes modular and reusable code, which can improve maintainability and scalability.
Strong community and ecosystem : React has a large and active community, offering a wealth of resources, third-party libraries, and plugins to extend its functionality.
Well-established best practices : Due to its maturity, React has a wealth of best practices and design patterns that can guide developers in building efficient and maintainable applications.
Flexibility : React's JSX syntax allows for more flexibility in terms of logic and composition within components, which can lead to more expressive and powerful code.
Comparing Developer Experiences
Both Svelte and React offer distinct developer experiences that cater to different preferences and requirements. Svelte focuses on simplicity and ease of use, with an intuitive syntax and built-in features that minimize the need for external libraries. React, on the other hand, emphasizes a component-based architecture and a flexible syntax, backed by a mature ecosystem and strong community support.
In this article, we've explored the differences between Svelte and React, focusing on their architecture, reactivity, syntax, and developer experience. Both frameworks have unique strengths and cater to different preferences and project requirements:
React provides a flexible and powerful syntax with JSX, along with a strong community and ecosystem that offer a wealth of resources and third-party libraries. React's virtual DOM and component-based architecture have been tried and tested, making it a popular choice for many developers.
Ultimately, the choice between Svelte and React depends on your personal preferences, development style, and project requirements. By understanding the differences and strengths of each framework, you can make an informed decision and choose the one that best aligns with your needs. As you embark on your next project, consider experimenting with both frameworks to gain firsthand experience and discover which one is the right fit for you.
Is Svelte better than React?
Yes, Svelte is better than React in certain aspects , and it can provide an overall better experience depending on your specific needs and context. For beginners or developers who prioritize a quicker, smoother learning curve, Svelte could be the preferred choice due to its simplicity and minimalistic design.
Svelte also stands out when it comes to building prototypes quickly, as it offers a faster feedback loop compared to React.
In terms of performance, Svelte can deliver better outcomes as it compiles your code to efficient, imperative code that directly manipulates the DOM. This makes Svelte applications generally faster and less memory intensive.
Is Svelte easier to learn than React?
Is Svelte faster than React?
Svelte is typically faster than React , and this is largely due to the fundamental differences in their underlying architecture.
React uses a concept called the Virtual DOM (VDOM), which is an abstract copy of the original DOM. When a change occurs, React first performs this change on the VDOM, then compares the updated VDOM with the previous one to identify the differences. It then makes the smallest possible changes to the actual DOM. This diffing and patching process, while efficient compared to manual DOM manipulation, still requires resources and can lead to slower performance in large or complex applications.
Svelte, on the other hand, takes a completely different approach. Instead of using a virtual DOM, Svelte compiles your code into highly efficient, imperative code that surgically updates the DOM as state changes. This means that Svelte does its 'diffing' at compile time while your app is being built, instead of at run time while your app is being used. As a result, a Svelte app does not need the extra overhead of a virtual DOM, and this results in faster updates and smoother performance.
Furthermore, because Svelte applications are smaller, they load and start faster. The smaller bundle size directly results from Svelte's compile-step optimization, which includes tree-shaking to remove unused code, and results in a leaner, more performant final application.
What are the disadvantages of Svelte?
The main disadvantage of Svelte is its relatively smaller community compared to older, more established frameworks like React or Vue. This means fewer resources, like tutorials and libraries.
However, it's worth noting that the Svelte community is growing rapidly and has seen a lot of adoption in recent years.
Is Svelte popular?
Yes, Svelte is gaining popularity and wide adoption across the web development industry.
Its simple, efficient, and intuitive design philosophy appeals to many developers. Svelte is backed by big companies like Vercel, where Rich Harris, the founder of Svelte, works full-time on Svelte and SvelteKit.
Do any big companies use Svelte?
Yes, many big companies like NBA, Apple, Yelp, New York Times, IKEA, Spotify, Square, Cloudflare, Brave, and Decathlon use Svelte. You can read more about this here.
Is Apple using Svelte?
Yes, Apple has been using Svelte for many years. In fact, the web version of Apple Music is entirely powered by Svelte.
Is Svelte easy to learn?
Are there any Svelte or SvelteKit agencies out there?
Yes, Okupter is an agency that specializes in Svelte and SvelteKit for building highly performant, accessible, and SEO-optimized landing pages, marketing sites, web applications, and MVPs with Svelte and SvelteKit.
You can check our sprint based Svelte and SvelteKit development service .